"Commentary on a note published in Clarín newspaper on 31 January 2011, in particular the way it was entitled." Rupture of the PC to take hostage the writing for a few days "justifies" the delay.
"Neither the social exclusion or inequality justifies the choice of crime"
This title was published a notice in the Daily Bugle. Then extracts of the note, the following subtitle: "We serve the whole of Freud's ideas, there are now forms of crime indifferent to blame."
"Neither the social exclusion or inequality justifies the choice of crime"
This title was published a notice in the Daily Bugle. Then extracts of the note, the following subtitle: "We serve the whole of Freud's ideas, there are now forms of crime indifferent to blame."
respondents did not know who titled his notes and they often do not approve of titles that are published opinions, this paper also sheds themselves interviewer that at times are confused with the interviewee. In the case justify the use of the verb, not causally related to two statements, used as a mechanism to explain neurosis acts whose determinations are unknown, is the least problematic. If supported with regard to analytical act, a little more explicit the condensate is the sort of sophistry, I could go on, there in every act a dimension of uncertainty of the data can not determine the conclusion from them, if not is the addition of a plus, something on the order of choice that provides what is lacking in the initial data and we can call, without pushing things too much, a subject such as Jacques Lacan follows Freud's experience. The a priori with the author preceding the conclusion, and that the editor omitted from the title scrolling, and it is clear that precedes social exclusion, also omitted, modalizarían the phrase in a better direction. Initial data social exclusion and inequality, as any other data, such as wealth does not justify any further act or choice for the crime or any other option. The shape of the universal negative, devoid of any element, since there is no reason at all, to illustrate a particular anyone, something that does not happen in any case, however produces a certain effect, other than if you had used the example of wealth or anything else, not determined anything. Although different structure, it is worth recalling an example of like Freud who is punished as saying "anyone who says that the king is an ass, you have to deal with me." Imagine how titled the editor in question.
The construction of the concept of insecurity directly related to crime, its current role in election campaigns in the region, and the fight against local media, the way that creates a "feel" without regard to the "real" data (stop by the time the supposed reality of the statistics) make the linkage to other concepts: social exclusion and inequality, education, psychology, biology, etc. determine fields and modes of intervention, as well as resource allocation (as a privilege or other social programs, resources educational psychologists squads, etc.). Which it refers to social exclusion and inequality, does not seem worse than it binds to education, and certainly better than it binds to a psychology, psychopathology implicit in this connection. If, as we saw, the theory of the subject in psychoanalysis prevents justify, and in fairness to the respondent him restore their a priori choice of the initial conditions, no objection, nor confirms the establishment of relations. Beyond that psychoanalysis can enrich criminology and what can illuminate this: Why would the goal keeper or ratify a the relationship between crime and social exclusion, on the other side can have its validity for example in the field of sociology? Show on behalf of psychoanalysis, the crime out of social conflict and join either the dark forces of modernity, science, etc. generated by "corrupt" ancient compasses as the father of accidents in early relationships with the mother's psychopathology associated with acute, or des-blamed the alleged present age. Do they allow better justify the above crime?
If we move on to the title and subtitle the thing gets even more complicated, psychoanalysis is outmoded state to account of affairs.
"We do not serve at all the ideas of Freud. Today there are ways indifferent to blame crime " captioning. According to the "today", with which you are trying to separate from aging, second actual theoretical references to Freud, "yesterday", Freud, would: first, a theory about the crime and then its central concept would the notion of guilt, as current decline would anachronistic "the ideas of Freud," What? Do all in a bag? Which you also allowed to raise a subject like the one mentioned above? But a moment suspend our cleaning and see, before pulling anything more than what Freud said.
Freud and crime and blameless because
advanced his work Freud theorized and inversely correlated with guilt and cultural development, the first as the price paid by the second. Long before establishing the second topic and novelty, the superego, are references to its operation, and the presence of an instance tormenting self-reproach is present from the beginning of his clinic, but its explicit reference to this problem in the text of 1916 mentioned in the note. In this brief text, in the last of the three sections of two pages, said that among his patients some in their youth have committed certain prohibited acts, theft, fire, or something like that, (yesterday, defecate in a school opposite the bust of Sarmiento, today, breaking the bust Ronald Mac Donnald). What can be thought of as symptomatic imagining a little profile of Freud's patients. And then he says that, before I thought it was because of weakness of teenage morality, since morality would have an evolutionary origin from low to high, now, and with the appearance as well in treating patients today have a similar behavior relocates these phenomena in relation to guilt, and sets the familiar formula which reverses the conventional sequence-fault crime. For these cases, first guilt after the crime, and punishment calming the first, mentioning also the following paragraph that was already in the aphorisms of Nietzsche Zarathustra. Lacan for his part what it proposes as self-punishment paranoia in relation to them, proposing to the already established at that time, I crimes and crimes of this, the crimes of the superego.
But back to Freud, also in the same article says that there are others who commit crimes without guilt. It says there that are out of the Oedipus complex or neurosis, but either have no moral inhibitions, and this must be to correlate with the first article of the series entitled "exceptions" because in their struggle against society are created "justified" in their actions. Interesting idea to think about the social exclusion related crime, the subject and the Other, that is the addition of a justification does believe something that trade.
If we expand a little this separation of the fields proposed by Freud with concepts that have a few years later, where the operation will be described theorized the notion of the superego, citing examples of the work of one of his disciples those most interested in this notion, F. Alexander, the crimes may be called to calm the severity of the superego may relate to children raised with the utmost love and kindness of parents over preventing aggression target was another location other than I own. Too permissive education could provide a very severe superego, and a very severe superego education more peaceful. This is not mirrored to the parent, may be the reverse, but it is independent of it, Freudian paradoxes. The other side of abandoned children, at least the years of experience Aichhorn, seems not to meet this problem of tension between ego and superego and aggressive impulses can be directed towards outside and if offenders can not be blamed too much to the fault of the superego. Surely now is not an orphanage but replicating the terms of the note, the vulnerability of a social class, which does not, and can even lead to compensation, in the case of teenage mothers, too much love for a child . As seen the thing but has different edges, coinciding with the interviewee, but not so with "today" because neither was "yesterday", not a good idea to look for the offenders by Freud's sense of guilt among Young called jets. He added that, beyond a remark about the effect of the presentation of the note, or any extension that I use to the case, it seems very healthy to shake the idea and discuss some ideas as automatic repeat crystallization and its effect has been removed.
Lacan-Freud law and love.
Lacanian formula maddening mother, estragante, normalizing law of the father has been very successful not only in sectors "psychic", but also judges, teachers, desperate mothers, and all they want. It can be found behind many of the interventions in fields such as social (I call them to psychologists and social t. operating on children and adolescents at risk or in conflict with the law), education, judiciary (judges always waiting for the desired internalization of the law, is a good illustration of how to address the problem) etc. But the same success was not the part that Lacan, it takes advantage that off. But, and here we follow the respondent, the law cited does not refer to the legal law, the social control that fun without implying any psychosis. I always liked the junction under the effect of the joke, had the saying of a famous psychoanalyst, very consistent on this occasion: "If we go by the statements given by the agents, a place as prison is full of innocent people, I blame for something I did not, and a drunken bar guilty, she left me for my fault. " Variety of laws and blames the author of the article refers.
But back to Freud, references to the fault in the article cited in footnote related to incest and parricide as laws of the culture. But when a few years later introduced the superego, in which accounts of feeling (conscious-unconscious diagnostic value of clinical structure) of guilt, it is bound to risk the loss of love, first external Another after internalized their instance, the superego. While this term subsumes Freud developed by him before and Ideal Introduction of self in narcissism and psychology of the masses, but appear not to refer to exactly the same and perhaps makes it so ironic that the term (the title of the chapter of his introduction is the superego and ego Ideal parentheses). Jacques Lacan for his part preferred to keep separate its nuances a good time. In a move similar to that of Freud, Lacan in the 70 resumes operation of the metaphor of a preliminary matter including love, absent this time, operation now treated in terms of coining the name of the father.
ideals do not already there?
"But that paradigm Freud no longer exists, because the social and cultural ideals have lost the strength to direct the lives of people "
Surely" some "ideals have lost the strength to direct and perhaps others have taken, if agreed, following Lacan the importance given to the establishment of narcissism from Freud, and where I, as well as their perception, awareness, etc. libidinizada is an image that gives us pleasure. For the topic at hand, we can steal from that prestige, (let's leave the time circumscribed by the subgroup in question, although you can extend the range without problems) would be difficult not to consider an ideal and strong in the groups of adolescents, offenders and even those who do not blend in with its epic and linguistic expressions, get prominence and girls in the corner, and some other privileges (I leave without taking the reverse of pibas jets, with women you never know). The alleged fall from the ideal may be exacerbations of it, for example in the post-modern ideal of having no ideal. We can discuss in another context that further, if any, takes the feature of the ideal, but the ideal-dialectical identification established by Freud can keep your interest for the case. Recall that Lacan produced new interpretations of Psychology of the masses far into their teaching. Moreover, in addition to these changes in relation to the ideal, there are also changes in the vectors at play in the identi. The vertical axis identification adults lost in relation to the horizontal identifications among teenagers and even reversed its direction, now is the great who wants to be young and not vice versa.
Finally I note only that the addictive and criminal issues are often associated but not the same. In my experience working with adolescents in conflict with the law, the field of adolescent crime is a group, most steals in a "buddy" or more, which may not coincide with loneliness oppressed by the criminal's fault, or the solitary enjoyment of the abuser. Ditto for the circulation and exchange of objects algalmáticos slippers, which begins with the stolen money. Remains to be seen in that space constituted by the social bond issue at stake in criminal and present in the construction of the net outside the penal code, which relates the author rightly note, the possibilities to operate.
The construction of the concept of insecurity directly related to crime, its current role in election campaigns in the region, and the fight against local media, the way that creates a "feel" without regard to the "real" data (stop by the time the supposed reality of the statistics) make the linkage to other concepts: social exclusion and inequality, education, psychology, biology, etc. determine fields and modes of intervention, as well as resource allocation (as a privilege or other social programs, resources educational psychologists squads, etc.). Which it refers to social exclusion and inequality, does not seem worse than it binds to education, and certainly better than it binds to a psychology, psychopathology implicit in this connection. If, as we saw, the theory of the subject in psychoanalysis prevents justify, and in fairness to the respondent him restore their a priori choice of the initial conditions, no objection, nor confirms the establishment of relations. Beyond that psychoanalysis can enrich criminology and what can illuminate this: Why would the goal keeper or ratify a the relationship between crime and social exclusion, on the other side can have its validity for example in the field of sociology? Show on behalf of psychoanalysis, the crime out of social conflict and join either the dark forces of modernity, science, etc. generated by "corrupt" ancient compasses as the father of accidents in early relationships with the mother's psychopathology associated with acute, or des-blamed the alleged present age. Do they allow better justify the above crime?
If we move on to the title and subtitle the thing gets even more complicated, psychoanalysis is outmoded state to account of affairs.
"We do not serve at all the ideas of Freud. Today there are ways indifferent to blame crime " captioning. According to the "today", with which you are trying to separate from aging, second actual theoretical references to Freud, "yesterday", Freud, would: first, a theory about the crime and then its central concept would the notion of guilt, as current decline would anachronistic "the ideas of Freud," What? Do all in a bag? Which you also allowed to raise a subject like the one mentioned above? But a moment suspend our cleaning and see, before pulling anything more than what Freud said.
Freud and crime and blameless because
advanced his work Freud theorized and inversely correlated with guilt and cultural development, the first as the price paid by the second. Long before establishing the second topic and novelty, the superego, are references to its operation, and the presence of an instance tormenting self-reproach is present from the beginning of his clinic, but its explicit reference to this problem in the text of 1916 mentioned in the note. In this brief text, in the last of the three sections of two pages, said that among his patients some in their youth have committed certain prohibited acts, theft, fire, or something like that, (yesterday, defecate in a school opposite the bust of Sarmiento, today, breaking the bust Ronald Mac Donnald). What can be thought of as symptomatic imagining a little profile of Freud's patients. And then he says that, before I thought it was because of weakness of teenage morality, since morality would have an evolutionary origin from low to high, now, and with the appearance as well in treating patients today have a similar behavior relocates these phenomena in relation to guilt, and sets the familiar formula which reverses the conventional sequence-fault crime. For these cases, first guilt after the crime, and punishment calming the first, mentioning also the following paragraph that was already in the aphorisms of Nietzsche Zarathustra. Lacan for his part what it proposes as self-punishment paranoia in relation to them, proposing to the already established at that time, I crimes and crimes of this, the crimes of the superego.
But back to Freud, also in the same article says that there are others who commit crimes without guilt. It says there that are out of the Oedipus complex or neurosis, but either have no moral inhibitions, and this must be to correlate with the first article of the series entitled "exceptions" because in their struggle against society are created "justified" in their actions. Interesting idea to think about the social exclusion related crime, the subject and the Other, that is the addition of a justification does believe something that trade.
If we expand a little this separation of the fields proposed by Freud with concepts that have a few years later, where the operation will be described theorized the notion of the superego, citing examples of the work of one of his disciples those most interested in this notion, F. Alexander, the crimes may be called to calm the severity of the superego may relate to children raised with the utmost love and kindness of parents over preventing aggression target was another location other than I own. Too permissive education could provide a very severe superego, and a very severe superego education more peaceful. This is not mirrored to the parent, may be the reverse, but it is independent of it, Freudian paradoxes. The other side of abandoned children, at least the years of experience Aichhorn, seems not to meet this problem of tension between ego and superego and aggressive impulses can be directed towards outside and if offenders can not be blamed too much to the fault of the superego. Surely now is not an orphanage but replicating the terms of the note, the vulnerability of a social class, which does not, and can even lead to compensation, in the case of teenage mothers, too much love for a child . As seen the thing but has different edges, coinciding with the interviewee, but not so with "today" because neither was "yesterday", not a good idea to look for the offenders by Freud's sense of guilt among Young called jets. He added that, beyond a remark about the effect of the presentation of the note, or any extension that I use to the case, it seems very healthy to shake the idea and discuss some ideas as automatic repeat crystallization and its effect has been removed.
Lacan-Freud law and love.
Lacanian formula maddening mother, estragante, normalizing law of the father has been very successful not only in sectors "psychic", but also judges, teachers, desperate mothers, and all they want. It can be found behind many of the interventions in fields such as social (I call them to psychologists and social t. operating on children and adolescents at risk or in conflict with the law), education, judiciary (judges always waiting for the desired internalization of the law, is a good illustration of how to address the problem) etc. But the same success was not the part that Lacan, it takes advantage that off. But, and here we follow the respondent, the law cited does not refer to the legal law, the social control that fun without implying any psychosis. I always liked the junction under the effect of the joke, had the saying of a famous psychoanalyst, very consistent on this occasion: "If we go by the statements given by the agents, a place as prison is full of innocent people, I blame for something I did not, and a drunken bar guilty, she left me for my fault. " Variety of laws and blames the author of the article refers.
But back to Freud, references to the fault in the article cited in footnote related to incest and parricide as laws of the culture. But when a few years later introduced the superego, in which accounts of feeling (conscious-unconscious diagnostic value of clinical structure) of guilt, it is bound to risk the loss of love, first external Another after internalized their instance, the superego. While this term subsumes Freud developed by him before and Ideal Introduction of self in narcissism and psychology of the masses, but appear not to refer to exactly the same and perhaps makes it so ironic that the term (the title of the chapter of his introduction is the superego and ego Ideal parentheses). Jacques Lacan for his part preferred to keep separate its nuances a good time. In a move similar to that of Freud, Lacan in the 70 resumes operation of the metaphor of a preliminary matter including love, absent this time, operation now treated in terms of coining the name of the father.
ideals do not already there?
"But that paradigm Freud no longer exists, because the social and cultural ideals have lost the strength to direct the lives of people "
Surely" some "ideals have lost the strength to direct and perhaps others have taken, if agreed, following Lacan the importance given to the establishment of narcissism from Freud, and where I, as well as their perception, awareness, etc. libidinizada is an image that gives us pleasure. For the topic at hand, we can steal from that prestige, (let's leave the time circumscribed by the subgroup in question, although you can extend the range without problems) would be difficult not to consider an ideal and strong in the groups of adolescents, offenders and even those who do not blend in with its epic and linguistic expressions, get prominence and girls in the corner, and some other privileges (I leave without taking the reverse of pibas jets, with women you never know). The alleged fall from the ideal may be exacerbations of it, for example in the post-modern ideal of having no ideal. We can discuss in another context that further, if any, takes the feature of the ideal, but the ideal-dialectical identification established by Freud can keep your interest for the case. Recall that Lacan produced new interpretations of Psychology of the masses far into their teaching. Moreover, in addition to these changes in relation to the ideal, there are also changes in the vectors at play in the identi. The vertical axis identification adults lost in relation to the horizontal identifications among teenagers and even reversed its direction, now is the great who wants to be young and not vice versa.
Finally I note only that the addictive and criminal issues are often associated but not the same. In my experience working with adolescents in conflict with the law, the field of adolescent crime is a group, most steals in a "buddy" or more, which may not coincide with loneliness oppressed by the criminal's fault, or the solitary enjoyment of the abuser. Ditto for the circulation and exchange of objects algalmáticos slippers, which begins with the stolen money. Remains to be seen in that space constituted by the social bond issue at stake in criminal and present in the construction of the net outside the penal code, which relates the author rightly note, the possibilities to operate.
Gustavo Gonzalez
0 comments:
Post a Comment